UNSC: Room for Reform?
The United Nations Security Council: Is there room for reform?
As many global conflicts worsen, many may ask as to how and why these crises prevail despite the existence of the United Nations, and more specifically, the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) which is thought to prevent this. To understand this issue, we must look into the actual powers of the member states of the United Nations, the strength of the Security Council in managing world conflicts and criticisms and debates for reform regarding this.
What is the United Nations and what do they stand for?
Firstly, to broaden baseline knowledge, the United Nations is identified as the largest and most prominent intergovernmental organization in the world, containing 193 sovereign member states plus 2 permanent observer states (the Holy See and the State of Palestine).These states form the General Assembly with its headquarters located in New York and other prominent offices in Geneva, Vienna and Nairobi
Key aspects include maintaining peace and security (this will be looked into further shortly), delivering humanitarian aid, promoting sustainable development, protecting human rights and most importantly upholding international law. A notable successful UN peacekeeping mission includes the United Nations Mission in Liberia (UNMIL) from 2003-2018 where the UN helped to disarm and reintegrate former combatants and reform the police and judicial systems to foster a peaceful democracy. This, among many other missions, demonstrates the importance and impact the UN can have in global affairs.
The Security Council
Now onto the Security Council, which is made up of 15 members total, with 5 members being the most powerful states within the United Nations. They are known as the Permanent 5 (P5) and are made up of the United States, China, Russia, France and the United Kingdom. These 5 states have the ability to issue resolutions that are legally binding on all UN member states (the only body in the UN system with this power) and have veto power to block any decision with only 1 state veto required to do this. Otherwise, to pass a resolution, at least 9 of the 15 member states must vote in favour and as mentioned before, one ‘no’ vote from a P5 member results in a resolution failing, The other 10 non permanent members are elected by the UN General Assembly for overlapping two-year terms. Notable countries at the moment include Greece, Panama, Columbia, Pakistan and Somalia with the presidency of the council rotating monthly among its 15 members in alphabetical order.
To understand the key criticisms of the UNSC, we need to look at their core roles and functions as a group and how they come to key decisions. At a basic level, these include investigating international despite and identified threats to peace, deploying UN peacekeeping operations or authorising member states to use “all necessary means” to stop aggression, impose sanctions against states, groups or individuals and as aforementioned, issue resolutions that all UN member states are legally required to obey. This could be seen in The Gulf War between 1990-1991 in which Iraq invaded Kuwait, resulting in the UNSC to demand an immediate Iraqi withdrawal, passing Resolution 678 in November of 1990. This authorised member states co-operating with the government of Kuwait to use "all necessary means" to restore international peace and security if Iraq did not withdraw by January 15, 1991. Ultimately, after Iraq failed to comply with the deadline, a US led international coalition defeated Iraqi forces and liberated Kuwait City by February 1991, showing the strong influence of the resolutions of the Security Council.
Criticisms of the UNSC
As our basic understanding of the UN and the Security Council is now formed, we can discuss each key point of criticism, long standing debates surrounding it and potential reforms to be made.
Veto power
First and foremost, the biggest point of contention regarding the UNSC has to be the veto power of P5 which can block any resolution, even with overwhelming support from the rest of the general assembly.
This often prevents the SC from intervening in major international conflicts and human rights violations. A key current example being the US casting multiple lone vetos regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict with its impact being the blocking of formal UN directives that would have put an end to hostilities, protecting medical personnel, and opening immediate, unrestricted pathways for humanitarian relief. Other criticisms include that it grants outdated privilege to five states based on post WWII powers, ignoring other capable present day stable states as well the P5’s ability to shield themselves from accountability and sanctions with their veto of a decision.
Reform proposals to veto power
Countries such as France and Mexico propose the voluntarily suspending the veto in cases of mass atrocities such as genocide or war crimes, as seen in the Israel-Palestine conflict. Nations such as Turkey also advocate for phasing out or reducing the power and existence of the veto in order to give the elected 10 of the General Assembly on the SC a stronger voice.
Operational failures
Another strong point of criticism also stems from the UNSC’s inability to actually stop wars and humanitarian disasters which is followed by many explanations. The most obvious being the mentioned veto power, especially Russia’s throughout its current war with Ukraine. Other justifications offer that due to the lack of an independent UN army, there is no worldwide force to intervene. This is because any enforcement action or peacekeeping mission depends entirely on member nations voluntarily contributing troops, equipment, and funding which doesn't happen very often and if so, are only sent in after a ceasefire and not during the conflict.
Reform proposals to operational failures
The Act Group Code of Conduct led by Accountability, Coherence, and Transparency group asks all SC members to not to vote against credible and sensible solutions aimed at preventing or halting mass atrocities, similar to the France-Mexico Initiative mentioned previously. Other reforms propose expanding the permanent membership to be more representative, particularly of African states, and including major contemporary powers such as Brazil, Germany, India and Japan to correct structural gridlock over major conflicts with the current P5
Double standards
Due to veto powers, a single P5 nation can block actions against itself, its allies, or its strategic interests, effectively placing them above international law. This creates clear power imbalances between the SC and the General Assembly, clearly demonstrating some states artificially have more global power over others. A key example being Russia's ability to veto to block action to halt its full scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 with its attacks still ongoing in the current day. Furthemore, the UNSC frequently lectures smaller member states on good governance, rule of law, and democracy however the concept of the UNSC itself is highlighted as undemocratic and outdated, seeing as it was established based on WWII dynamics which are over 80 years old.
Reform proposals for double standards
The G4 Coalition of Brazil, Germany, India and Japan propose to expand the council to 25-26 seats, adding six new permanent seats (2 Africa, 2 Asia, 1 Latin America, 1 Western Europe) in order to ensure equal representation. On the other side of this argument lies the proposal from Italy, Pakistan and Mexico in which they oppose the expansion of permanent seats but instead stand for the expansion of non-permanent seats with longer, renewable terms in order to dilute the veto power.
With increasing global pressures regarding this issue constantly being on the rise, we can expect to see change take place eventually, however, what measures it will take or what reforms will we see in our lifetime is still in question.



Comments